Why is bsl wrong

This is because:. Animal control and legislative approaches to protecting a community from dangerous dogs should not be based on breed, but instead on promoting responsible pet ownership and developing methods to rapidly identify and respond to owners whose dogs present an actual risk. AVMA's report A Community Approach to Dog Bite Prevention PDF highlights tangible steps that veterinarians can take alongside state and local leaders to implement effective dog bite prevention programs in their community.

Letter from veterinarian. Letter from state VMA. New veterinarian Answers to the questions you're facing as you start out in your professional life. Rising professional Early-career resources to continue your professional and personal growth. Diversity, equity, and inclusion Creating socially conscious work environments. Wellbeing Self-care and workplace wellbeing for the whole veterinary team.

Practice management Profitability and finance, marketing, leadership, and team building. Personal finances Loans, budgets, financial planning, and more. One Health Interprofessional collaboration across animal, human, and environmental health. Public resources Pet owners K educators.

Calendar of events Live webinars Awareness events. Featured events Applications due: Wellbeing educator training November BSL does not take into consideration that all dogs are individuals, with their own unique behaviors and personalities. So, why is BSL ineffective? The two main factors come down to the inability to effectively enforce and lack of correlation to improvement of public safety. BSL is virtually impossible to enforce. Why is this? Pit bull is essentially a slang term used to describe a group of dogs that encompass a set of certain physical characteristics.

Often, these dogs are of unknown origin but may possess a large chest, muscular composure, and certain facial structure. There is no correlation to improvement of public safety. In fact, in a recent report from Dr. With statistics like this and the rise of mixed breeds, many professional organizations and researchers have deemed visual identification of dogs as ineffective.

They argue that if a person is unable to accurately identify a breed, how are they able to label them as dangerous? Along with this, the American Veterinary Medical Association has noted that there has been no evidence collected to date which clearly shows that one particular breed is more likely to harm someone than another. It is because of this they argue, that when it comes to identifying dogs which could potentially pose a threat to others, clues should be drawn from the dogs individual behavior as opposed to appearance.

This means that it can change from place to place and person to person, making it an ineffective way to categorize potentially dangerous dogs. In fact most kennel clubs around the world do not recognize pit-bulls as a specific breed.

These dogs were mistreated, were tethered or confined, or were allowed to play with children without adult supervision. In this case it is not fair, they argue, to compare these dogs those owned by responsible people. The study found that most dogs which are kept in a loving, residential environment were not likely to be harmful to others. Breed-Specific Legislation in this case punishes even those who have properly trained and take good care of their dogs. Although this may seem like an effective method to avoid detection, it often leads to the dogs being subjected to less than ideal circumstances.

Some of these harmful consequences include: restricted outdoor exercise, limited veterinarian care and not being properly licensed or microchipped. In this case BSL is deemed as ineffective as the health consequences experienced by these dogs, far outweigh the likelihood that they will be a threat or harmful towards an individual. Rebels will just switch to another non-outlawed breed People who are committed to owning dogs for dangerous purposes, like dog-fighting and other criminal activities, will work around the breed-ban by just switching to a non-outlawed breed.

Bull-Terriers are considered part of the BSL in some states. Some of these dogs play an important role in the community Many dogs who fall under the BSL have both throughout history and in current times played an important role in their community. These dogs have acted as therapy dogs, assistance dogs, search and rescue dogs, police dogs, or drug detection dogs. In this case, removing these dogs from their beneficial community roles, poses far more consequences than benefits.

BSL creates a shift away from proper enforcement and is extremely costly Enforcing dog license and leash laws, animal-fighting laws, promoting spaying and neutering and other similar regulations, is important to public safety, regardless of the breed. When BSL is in place, limited resources are used to focus only on banned breeds, as opposed to regulating all pets and animals as a whole. BSL is also extremely costly and requires a large portion of tax payers dollars.

Most people would mistakenly walk up and think my lab was the one who wouldnt bite vs my pit and would be very wrong. My black adorable lab was times more likely to be the one to bite, even attack. We never knew why, figured she may have been abused. Just goes to show, if I was out with both dogs with out a doubt people would trust the wrong dog to pet. My pit would love it, my lab depended, but likely to be the one to bite.

Thank you for sharing that. My dog was charged at the dog park by a lab, whose owner profusely apologized as he tackled his dog and dragged him out.

Luckily my dog was only left with wounds that did not require much treatment, and I had bites that did require stitches.

It came out of nowhere, and my dog did not bite back or instigate it. He was simply doing his run as fast as I can in circles around the park…it must have triggered some wierd prey drive in the lab. My dog looks somewhat similar to a pit, but is not one. My mother too had one lab for years he was over lbs and lived to be almost 15!

She had 2 others who were lovebugs and I have owned a lab myself. My son was attacked and bit in the face while playing a board game by the neighbors german shepherd. Breeds do not determine what is expected. People do by treatment, bad breeding, abuse. I agree with regulations that deal with that. Specific dogs and people. I am coming to you with a sad heart…my neighbor has 3 pitbulls that they let regularly run free for exercise…they have killed numerous of my other neighbors pets.

They have been warned and there is no animal control here. I have been run into my own home and now my sweet puff kitty that was in our yard got mauled to death. She was 8. I cannot express my grief and sadness. I now will be my own animal control when they come back in my yard. Here is what it all boils down to for me, and I am not trying to offend anyone by saying this, but. Of course not, that is just asinine, and to believe that one type of dog, which includes multiple different dog breeds, are all the same is asinine as well.

This is just my own person thought though. People not watching there own kids will let them crawl into an animal enclosure and end up dead or badly injured. The Humane Society of the United States is registered as a c 3 non-profit organization.

Contributions to The Humane Society of the United States are tax-deductible to the extent permitted by law. The HSUS's tax identification number is Subscribe to the Blog Enter your email address below to receive updates each time we publish new content.

Marie says:. January 31, at pm. Marisa says:. April 24, at pm. Violet says:. June 19, at am. Rachel says:. November 27, at pm. Ella says:. January 14, at pm. Ashlin Duncan says:. January 22, at am. Sam says:. Doglover says:. February 3, at am. Patricia Frederick says:. February 7, at pm. April 23, at pm. Eric Mills says:.

Annie Brown says:. February 1, at am. Sabrina says:. Tina says:. Lisa Waits says:. Taylor Roberts says:. February 1, at pm. Paul says:. Californians for Regulating Pit Bulls says:. Denise Duirway says:. Julie says:. Petunia Polly says:. Myresponseis says:. February 2, at pm. February 3, at pm. Amber says:. Henry George says:. Sonia Leclerc says:. AnimalLover says:. Drew says:. June 9, at am. Mihaela MJ says:. Mirl says:. February 2, at am.

February 4, at pm. Julie Wall says:. February 6, at pm. Diana says:. Deborah Tyler says:.